Head to Head

Broughton Rangers wins: 46
St. Helens wins: 60
Draws: 6
Abandoned: 0

Date Competition Competition Home Team Result Away Team Attendance Referee
Sat 05 Oct 1895 1895-96 Season League Broughton Rangers
3-5
 St. Helens
Thu 30 Apr 1896 1895-96 Season League St. Helens
26-0
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 12 Dec 1896 1896-97 Season Lancashire Senior Competition Broughton Rangers
3-0
 St. Helens
Sat 13 Feb 1897 1896-97 Season Lancashire Senior Competition St. Helens
10-20
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 09 Oct 1897 1897-98 Season Lancashire Senior Competition Broughton Rangers
0-8
 St. Helens
Sat 01 Jan 1898 1897-98 Season Lancashire Senior Competition St. Helens
6-23
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 10 Sep 1898 1898-99 Season Lancashire Senior Competition St. Helens
3-13
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 17 Dec 1898 1898-99 Season Lancashire Senior Competition Broughton Rangers
20-2
 St. Helens
Sat 30 Sep 1899 1899-00 Season Lancashire Senior Competition Broughton Rangers
0-14
 St. Helens
Mon 25 Dec 1899 1899-00 Season Lancashire Senior Competition St. Helens
4-0
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 01 Sep 1900 1900-01 Season Lancashire Senior Competition St. Helens
5-3
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 22 Dec 1900 1900-01 Season Lancashire Senior Competition Broughton Rangers
29-0
 St. Helens
Sat 29 Nov 1902 1902-03 Season League Broughton Rangers
23-0
 St. Helens
Sat 28 Mar 1903 1902-03 Season League St. Helens
3-18
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 24 Sep 1904 1904-05 Season League Broughton Rangers
24-5
 St. Helens
Sat 21 Jan 1905 1904-05 Season League St. Helens
6-8
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 18 Mar 1905 1904-05 Season Challenge Cup 2 (16) Broughton Rangers
18-0
 St. Helens
Sat 22 Dec 1906 1906-07 Season League St. Helens
7-14
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 02 Feb 1907 1906-07 Season League Broughton Rangers
27-11
 St. Helens
Sat 02 Nov 1907 1907-08 Season League Broughton Rangers
25-13
 St. Helens
Mon 13 Apr 1908 1907-08 Season League St. Helens
11-28
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 10 Oct 1908 1908-09 Season League Broughton Rangers
19-9
 St. Helens
Sat 09 Jan 1909 1908-09 Season League St. Helens
8-19
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 04 Sep 1909 1909-10 Season League Broughton Rangers
7-10
 St. Helens
Sat 01 Jan 1910 1909-10 Season League St. Helens
15-8
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 08 Oct 1910 1910-11 Season League St. Helens
31-2
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 28 Jan 1911 1910-11 Season League Broughton Rangers
14-7
 St. Helens
Sat 02 Dec 1911 1911-12 Season League St. Helens
10-5
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 06 Apr 1912 1911-12 Season League Broughton Rangers
21-5
 St. Helens
Sat 23 Nov 1912 1912-13 Season League St. Helens
20-12
 Broughton Rangers
Wed 09 Apr 1913 1912-13 Season League Broughton Rangers
22-11
 St. Helens
Sat 08 Nov 1913 1913-14 Season League St. Helens
18-8
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 27 Dec 1913 1913-14 Season League Broughton Rangers
11-0
 St. Helens
Sat 31 Oct 1914 1914-15 Season League St. Helens
5-6
 Broughton Rangers
Wed 14 Apr 1915 1914-15 Season League Broughton Rangers
31-8
 St. Helens
Sat 23 Aug 1919 1919-20 Season League St. Helens
28-2
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 27 Dec 1919 1919-20 Season League Broughton Rangers
15-0
 St. Helens
Sat 28 Aug 1920 1920-21 Season League Broughton Rangers
13-11
 St. Helens
Sat 30 Oct 1920 1920-21 Season Lancashire Cup QF Broughton Rangers
6-2
 St. Helens
Mon 28 Mar 1921 1920-21 Season League St. Helens
9-7
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 01 Oct 1921 1921-22 Season League Broughton Rangers
2-5
 St. Helens
Sat 25 Feb 1922 1921-22 Season Challenge Cup 1 (32) Broughton Rangers
13-0
 St. Helens
Sat 04 Mar 1922 1921-22 Season League St. Helens
14-9
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 21 Oct 1922 1922-23 Season League St. Helens
24-10
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 23 Dec 1922 1922-23 Season League Broughton Rangers
14-8
 St. Helens
Sat 20 Oct 1923 1923-24 Season League Broughton Rangers
2-7
 St. Helens
Mon 21 Apr 1924 1923-24 Season League St. Helens
21-6
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 22 Nov 1924 1924-25 Season League St. Helens
12-2
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 21 Mar 1925 1924-25 Season League Broughton Rangers
10-10
 St. Helens
Sat 19 Sep 1925 1925-26 Season League Broughton Rangers
7-3
 St. Helens
Sat 06 Feb 1926 1925-26 Season League St. Helens
24-8
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 08 Jan 1927 1926-27 Season League Broughton Rangers
7-15
 St. Helens
Sat 09 Apr 1927 1926-27 Season League St. Helens
16-0
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 01 Oct 1927 1927-28 Season League Broughton Rangers
2-6
 St. Helens
Sat 17 Mar 1928 1927-28 Season League St. Helens
24-0
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 15 Sep 1928 1928-29 Season League St. Helens
12-5
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 13 Oct 1928 1928-29 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) Broughton Rangers
10-15
 St. Helens
Tue 30 Apr 1929 1928-29 Season League Broughton Rangers
14-7
 St. Helens
Sat 12 Oct 1929 1929-30 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) Broughton Rangers
9-10
 St. Helens
Sat 02 Nov 1929 1929-30 Season League Broughton Rangers
3-8
 St. Helens
Sat 19 Apr 1930 1929-30 Season League St. Helens
31-17
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 24 Jan 1931 1930-31 Season League Broughton Rangers
0-0
 St. Helens
Sat 07 Mar 1931 1930-31 Season Challenge Cup QF Broughton Rangers
7-8
 St. Helens
Sat 11 Apr 1931 1930-31 Season League St. Helens
37-5
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 24 Oct 1931 1931-32 Season League Broughton Rangers
24-12
 St. Helens
Mon 18 Apr 1932 1931-32 Season League St. Helens
21-10
 Broughton Rangers
Mon 24 Oct 1932 1932-33 Season Lancashire Cup QF St. Helens
22-4
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 04 Mar 1933 1932-33 Season League Broughton Rangers
8-8
 St. Helens
Mon 17 Apr 1933 1932-33 Season League St. Helens
26-0
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 09 Dec 1933 1933-34 Season League Broughton Rangers
9-11
 St. Helens
Sat 16 Dec 1933 1933-34 Season League St. Helens
36-5
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 10 Nov 1934 1934-35 Season League Broughton Rangers
31-2
 St. Helens
Wed 01 May 1935 1934-35 Season League St. Helens
2-8
 Broughton Rangers
Thu 20 Feb 1936 1935-36 Season League St. Helens
6-14
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 07 Mar 1936 1935-36 Season League Broughton Rangers
23-0
 St. Helens
Sat 02 Jan 1937 1936-37 Season League Broughton Rangers
23-5
 St. Helens
Mon 29 Mar 1937 1936-37 Season League St. Helens
15-5
 Broughton Rangers
Thu 02 Sep 1937 1937-38 Season League St. Helens
7-6
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 11 Sep 1937 1937-38 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) St. Helens
0-11
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 26 Mar 1938 1937-38 Season League Broughton Rangers
19-12
 St. Helens
Sat 26 Nov 1938 1938-39 Season League Broughton Rangers
10-7
 St. Helens
Sat 17 Dec 1938 1938-39 Season League St. Helens
22-6
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 04 Nov 1939 1939-40 Season Lancashire League St. Helens
28-10
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 09 Dec 1939 1939-40 Season Lancashire League St. Helens
27-9
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 02 Mar 1940 1939-40 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) 1st leg St. Helens
26-7
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 09 Mar 1940 1939-40 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) 2nd leg Broughton Rangers
10-3
 St. Helens
Sat 23 Nov 1940 1940-41 Season Lancashire League St. Helens
23-3
 Broughton Rangers
Mon 03 Sep 1945 1945-46 Season League Broughton Rangers
5-11
 St. Helens
Sat 10 Nov 1945 1945-46 Season League St. Helens
8-10
 Broughton Rangers
Sat 16 Nov 1946 1946-47 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
10-10
 St. Helens
Mon 07 Apr 1947 1946-47 Season League St. Helens
10-12
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 08 Nov 1947 1947-48 Season League St. Helens
0-9
 Belle Vue Rangers
Thu 22 Apr 1948 1947-48 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
2-21
 St. Helens
Sat 15 Jan 1949 1948-49 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
5-17
 St. Helens
Sat 12 Mar 1949 1948-49 Season League St. Helens
18-0
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 15 Oct 1949 1949-50 Season League St. Helens
28-5
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 18 Mar 1950 1949-50 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
7-7
 St. Helens
Sat 13 Jan 1951 1950-51 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
9-8
 St. Helens
Sat 17 Mar 1951 1950-51 Season League St. Helens
13-4
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 01 Sep 1951 1951-52 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) 1st leg St. Helens
4-8
 Belle Vue Rangers
Thu 06 Sep 1951 1951-52 Season Lancashire Cup 1 (16) 2nd leg Belle Vue Rangers
2-2
 St. Helens
Sat 05 Jan 1952 1951-52 Season League St. Helens
5-6
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 09 Feb 1952 1951-52 Season Challenge Cup 1 (32) 1st leg St. Helens
6-5
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 16 Feb 1952 1951-52 Season Challenge Cup 1 (32) 2nd leg Belle Vue Rangers
4-9
 St. Helens
Sat 15 Mar 1952 1951-52 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
8-16
 St. Helens
Sat 21 Feb 1953 1952-53 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
7-20
 St. Helens
Sat 28 Feb 1953 1952-53 Season Challenge Cup 2 (16) St. Helens
28-0
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 11 Apr 1953 1952-53 Season League St. Helens
38-9
 Belle Vue Rangers
Sat 10 Oct 1953 1953-54 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
5-27
 St. Helens
Sat 05 Dec 1953 1953-54 Season League St. Helens
38-7
 Belle Vue Rangers
Wed 18 Aug 1954 1954-55 Season League Belle Vue Rangers
11-20
 St. Helens
Sat 02 Apr 1955 1954-55 Season League St. Helens
31-0
 Belle Vue Rangers